Observational study reviewing the local practice in Malta of ordering routine chest X-rays on every medical patient admitted to hospital

Sub-title
AuthorsN Schembri
S Schembri
T Fardon
AbstractObjective: To assess whether any additional information is obtained through the routine requesting of chest X-rays on all adult medical admissions. Design: Observational study. Setting: Accident and Emergency Department, St Luke's Hospital, Malta. Participants: All adult acute medical admissions, irrespective of age and gender. Main outcome measures: The number of cases where unexpected findings were reported on routine chest X-rays. Method: Participants were subdivided according to their smoking status as smokers, non-smokers and ex-smokers. They were then in turn divided into 2 age groups: <50 year-old, >50 year-old. The respective chest X-ray reports, as documented in the admission medical notes, were revisited and categorised as normal chest X-rays, confirming a diagnosis or whether unexpected findings were reported. Results: Out of a total of 109 patients assessed, 23 were smokers, 70 were non-smokers and 16 were ex-smokers. Normal chest X-rays were reported in 19, 41, and 4 of smokers, non-smokers, and ex-smokers respectively. Diagnosis was confirmed on chest X-rays in 1, 15, and 6 of smokers, nonsmokers, and ex-smokers respectively. Unexpected findings were diagnosed in 3 smokers, 14 non-smokers, and 6 ex-smokers making up a total of 23 cases out of the 109 gathered. Out of these 23 cases, 7 were unexpected findings requiring further investigation including: possible lung primary (2), newly diagnosed lung metastases (2), pneumonia (2), aortic aneurysm (1); 6 of these cases being in the >50 age group. Interestingly 3 were smokers. Conclusions: The practice of requesting routine chest X-rays in all patients admitted to medical wards is almost exclusively useful in those over the age of 50 years especially in smokers, We suggest reviewing current practice. practice.

Published in:
JournalMalta Medical Journal
Volume18 Supplement
Page
Date01/12/2006
Link to journal

Key wordsaccident and emergency, acute admission, audit, routine chest X ray

Compiled by: Dr. I. Stabile    Dr. J. Pace